Total Pageviews

Friday, August 29, 2014

New York City Stove Inventors & Their Inventions, 1795-1855, Part 1: 1795-1836

[In progress, 29 August 2014- & recently (16 Jan. 2015) resumed after a layoff since September.  When I put it to one side, it was almost complete to 1837, and semi-complete to 1850, i.e. it had the raw data but needed editing. However, my efforts last night resulted in a meltdown and loss of an evening's work, so I am going to chop this blog in two at 1836, the end of one sequence of patents and the beginning of another.]


This is an offshoot of my "Rise of the New York Stove Trade" post, where I was struck, but not surprised, by the number of the city's stove makers and sellers who made use of the US patent system. I already knew how important patents were to the stove business, and also how large a proportion of American patents in the early nineteenth century were contributed by inventors of what they thought of as new and improved cooking and heating devices.  I also knew that New York City was a significant place of stove invention, as well as (really, because it was) the largest single market.  But I had never had reason to look systematically and in some detail at the city's record of stove invention.


{more on & from the scholarly literature on "democratic invention" -- Khan, Sokoloff, Lamoreaux}


I will start with the first forty years of New York stove inventors and inventions, mostly because it always makes sense to begin at the beginning, but also because it won't take too long.  In 1836 an enormous fire consumed the US Patent Office and most of the nearly ten thousand records that it contained.  Patentees were invited to help reconstruct the lost files, and thereby protect their valuable intellectual property, but the proportion of patents that were or could be restored was not high.  As a result, for 50 of the first 68 stove patents taken out by New York inventors all we have, in most cases, are the bare bones -- number, name, title, patentee, etc.  I have added to these from city directories (and some other sources), which provide at least two items of significant information about most patentees: where they lived and/or carried on their business; and, more important, their trade or occupation. The latter is crucial: what it tells us is that stove patentees were mostly practical men, closely connected with the stove business or those parts of the metal trades closest to it.  This is entirely unsurprising, and quite consistent with what the best of the scholarly literature tells us about the era of "democratic invention" in the United States.


* * *   


[1808 Directory http://books.google.com/books?id=d4AVAAAAYAAJ ]

Youle, John. Construction of a Cabouse (caboose).  Number 96X, 1795. 

Youle, George. Cabouse. Number 675X, 1806.


The Youles (for whom see "The Rise of the New York Stove Trade" and "Cabouse, Cambosse, Cambouse, Camboose, Caboose") probably deserve to be thought of as the founders of the New York stove trade, in which they remained active between the mid-1790s and the mid-1820s.  John Youle went into partnership with the iron founder Paul A. Sabbaton, who had been general superintendent of Youle's works since 1810, by 1823, making and selling cabouses from their premises at 264 Water Street, but by 1825 seems to have died or retired from business.  George was still trading from 296 Water Street in 1827, but by the mid-1830s he too had disappeared.  However, his name and his stoves were still present: in 1835 and 1836, two other firms, Austin Packard & Co., Youle & Sabbaton's successors at 264 Water Street, and Charles Postley (see below) at 260-262 next door, still identified themselves in the city directory as makers of George Youle's Cabouses.


Youle, George. Caboose Stove apparatus for cooking and distilling, &c. Number 690X, 1806.


Youle, George. Caboose Cooking Stove. Number 742X, 1807.

Poudrell, Joseph. Economical Furnace or Stove. Number 844X, 1808 -- described in the 1808 City Directory as a "patent stove maker."

Youle, George. Caboose. Number 1112X, 1809.


Sherwood, A. (probably Andrew). Kitchen Stove. Number 1495X, 1811.

Sherwood, A. Drum Cooking Stove. Number 1497X, 1811 -- Andrew Sherwood was a turner (machinist) and pattern maker living on Spring Street in 1812.

[1812 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric1813newy]

Power, T. Stove. Number 1583X, 1811 -- the only Power in the 1812 Directory was partner in a firm of auctioneers and furniture dealers with premises on Wall and Park Streets.  There were two men called Thomas Powers, one with no stated business or occupation living on William Street, the other a mason living on Beach Street on the West Side. 


Hunt, C. Grate. Number 1686X, 1812 -- Charles Hunt, a brassfounder, lived at 117 Elm Street.  


[1813 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric3818long]

Postley, Charles. Cooking and Heating Stove. Number 2074X, 1814 -- see below.

Youle, George. Moveable Kitchen. Number 2160X, 1814.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Postley, Charles. Reservoir Cooking Stove. Number 2297X, 1815. Class 126/1R.


This is the very first restored patent.  Why?  

  • Perhaps because Postley was still actively involved in the trade in the late 1830s, while none of the other early New York stove patentees was similarly connected by then.
  • The fact that he considered it worth restoring, despite the fact that by the late 1830s it was no longer current, may have been because of its fundamental importance.  It was the first patent for a stove with a single downdraft flue, i.e. the gaseous combustion products ("smoke") wrapped around the oven, improving the distribution of heat within it and, at least in intention, and perhaps in effect, increasing the stove's efficiency (the amount of usable heat created by burning a given quantity of fuel).  
  • Postley may simply have been particularly proud of this invention; or he may have calculated that, by restoring his patent, he was preventing anybody else from claiming that they had invented the single downdraft flue in a new patent filing themselves, confident that nobody could produce conclusive documentary evidence to disprove them.  Postley's restored patent guaranteed that this fundamental design feature was demonstrable "prior art" in the trade, and not capable of forming the basis of any future patent claim. 


The fact that Postley's patent survives means that it is the first one we can access through the US Patent and Trademark Office's wonderful website, at http://pdfpiw.uspto.gov/.piw?docid=X0002297, the source of the illustration at the head of this entry.   


Postley's stove came in two configurations.  Both of them were plain, unadorned, slab-sided boxes, with no attempt at elegance except for the claw-footed cabriole legs they sat on.


  • The first was basically a variation on the standard Pennsylvania nine- or ten-plate stove (for which see "A Collection of Stoves from American Museums, I: Plate Stoves") with a small warming oven behind the firebox A, and two cooking holes E in the bottom of the oven D, into which two cooking vessels F could be placed -- an inconvenient arrangement which did not take.  There were tiny holes a in the top of the small and large ovens, to deal with the common criticism of baking or 'roasting' things in closed iron ovens, that steam could not escape and whatever was cooked could not 'breathe' as it did over an open fire.  The downdraft flue was at the front of the oven, to make sure that it was wrapped in heat on all sides.
  • The second configuration is the one that worked and sold.  It had a single oven B that was c. 6-9" high, 15-24" long, and 8-12" deep, "surrounded with heat" which was "more uniform ... than other stoves."  The stove was more convenient than a nine- or ten-plate, because the flue gases escaped up the chimney through a pipe collar at the back of the top plate, not the front. There were three cooking holes in the top plate, so that the bottoms of cooking vessels sat either straight over the fire (F) or right in the current of "smoke" when it was at its hottest.  The smoke went down the back of the oven and under its bottom plate, then along the bottom of the stove and up the rear.    


The stove's advantages were that "Roasting, Baking, and Boiling" could all be carried out at the same time, and to do this it "d[id] not consume more than one half the wood that common baking does, a boiler containing from 8 to 12 quarts will boil in 15 minutes ... and the grate (sic) advantage is that their price is within the reach of the poor in general, so as they can save the one half the fuel and keep their families more comfortable, some of those gentlemen that have them now in use say they do not consume more than one quarter of a cord of wood in a Winter month with an advantage of doing all their cooking and washing with the small fire." 


Postley's witnesses were Gilbert Heard and another whose name is indecipherable. There is no Gilbert Heard in the 1813, 1815, or 1823 Directories, but James and Nicholas Heard were Pearl Street merchants.


[For Postley and his stoves, see also the post "(Some of) The First Stove Advertisements in America."]


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lane, A. Stove. Number 2306X, 1815 -- not in the Directory.


Graham, J. Economical Stove. Number 2401X, 1815 -- there were numerous J. (James, John, Joseph) Grahams in the 1815 Directory, but my money would be on John Graham, a tinplate worker living on Greenwich St.


Seger, John. Family Cooking Machine. Number 2402X, 1815 -- a coppersmith at 248 Water Street.


Liebenau, H.F. Stove. Number 2667X, 1816 -- there was a Henry F. Libeneau, perruquier (wig-maker), at 38 Vesey Street.


Detroismonts, L.D. Construction of Chimneys, Stoves, and Fire-places. Number 2770X, 1817 -- not in the Directory.


Simpson, J.P. Stove. Number 2771X, 1817 -- Joseph P. Simpson had hardware stores at 139 Cherry Street and 5 The Bowery in 1815.  By 1823 he was "City Sealer" and also ran a stove manufactory at 17 The Bowery.  He was still in the stove business, at different addresses on Fulton, Greenwich, and Water Streets, in 1834-1836.  (See spreadsheet.)


Phoebus, W. Collecting, Regulating, and Retaining Heat in Stoves. Number 2874X, 1817 -- The Reverend William Phoebus lived at 7 Second Street.


Hunter, William T. Perpetual Oven. Number 2890X, 1818 -- Hunter was a baker, living on Front Street and with premises on Pine and Depeyster Streets.


Mount, R. & Mount, J. Stove. Number 2937X, 1818 -- Robert Mount had copper stores on Barclay and Vesey Streets; John Mount was a Water Street tinman.


Lane, A. Stove. Number 3000X, 1818.


Youle, George. Fire-hearth Range or Galley. Number 3087X, 1819.


Wilcox, Richard. Portable Rotary Oven. Number 3198X, 1820 -- not in 1815 or 1823 Directories.


Berrian, Richard & Class, Francis. Circular Open Stove or Fire-place. Number 3230X, 1820 -- Francis Class had a tin and hardware store on Chatham Street in 1823.  There were two Richard Berrians, only one of them (Richard P., Chamber St.) with a stated occupation, shipmaster.


Graham, C.M. Fire Grate Called Caloret. Number 3400X, 1821 -- the only C. Graham in the 1823 Directory was an attorney with an office on William Street.



[1823 Longworth Directory https://archive.org/details/longworthsameric4818long & Commercial Directory http://books.google.com/books?id=PZcKAAAAYAAJ]


Wilson, James. Making Franklin and Cooking Stoves. Number 3830X, 1824 -- for Wilson, see the posts "(Some of) The First Stove Advertisements in America,"  "The Rise of the New York Stove Trade," and "Cabouse, Cambosse, Cambouse, Camboose, Caboose."  Wilson had an earlier stove patent, the first for a Franklin Stove, Number X2450 (1816), taken out while he was still a merchant in Poughkeepsie.  For Wilson Franklins, see "A Collection of Stoves from American Museums, Part II: Franklins."



James, William T. Sink or Box-Hearth for Stoves. Number 3854X, 1824 -- for James, see also "(Some of) The First Stove Advertisements in America."  

James, like Wilson, was an out-of-towner with a more significant earlier invention, the saddlebags cooking stove, Number X2296 (1815), made when he resided in Union Village, a small community now part of Greenwich, NY, 200 miles north up the Hudson.  By 1823, and probably earlier, he had moved himself and his principal place of business to New York City, but retained a presence in the upstate market with a "factory" in Troy, and (through his partner Cornell) also had a distribution base in Boston.  James's sons Alanson and John were still in the New York City stove business in their father's old premises at 295 Water Street until the mid-1840s, but William himself had moved into the foundry and machine-building trade by the mid-1830s. 


The "sink or box-hearth" became a standard feature of stoves, whose makers used, copied, or generally just ignored James's patent, perhaps because it was not really an invention of his at all but more a matter of his being the first person to patent something that was already commonplace.  Basically it was a recess extending from below the firebox right under the front hearth of a stove, into which ashes fell.  A removable cover plate in the hearth allowed the ashes to be shovelled out more easily and with less dust and fire risk than if they had to be taken out via the stove's main front door.   


[1825 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric18256long]

Woodruff, O. Anthracite Coal Furnace. Number 4253X, 1825 -- Oliver Woodruff was a Pearl Street merchant, and the only O. Woodruff in the 1825 Directory, which is not to say that he was necessarily this O. Woodruff.  The significance of this patent is that it was the first one in New York for an appliance to burn the new wonder fuel, Pennsylvania anthracite, which was hardly available in the New York market at this time.  (See "A Nation of Stoves, Chapter 4: The Coming of Anthracite, c. 1820-1840.")  But as the patent is lost we cannot tell what sort of "furnace" he had designed to burn it, or for what purposes.


Sullivan, J.L. Anthracite Coal Furnace. Number 4276X, 1825.  The three John Sullivans in the 1825 and 1826 Directories were two laborers living on Pearl and Water Streets and a mason, but there was also Jeremiah, a grocer, on Catharine Street.  None of them has a clarifying middle initial or anything else to explain why they might have been the J.L. who followed Woodruff's lead in trying to devise an anthracite furnace. 


[1826 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric1826newy]

Mott, Stephen C. & Holmes, William. Grate and Blower for Coal. Number 4589X, 1826 -- Mott & Holmes were partners in a grate-making business at 197 Grand Street:  Mott was a brassfounder, Holmes a "whitesmith" (sheet-metal worker).  A "blower" was a plate placed in a fireplace to restrict the draft and assist ignition. Anthracite was particularly difficult to kindle in a conventional fireplace, so the attention to "blowers" in 1826 and 1827 points to grate-makers' attempts to modify their appliances for the new fuel.


[1827 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameri00longgoog & http://books.google.com/books?id=TYAVAAAAYAAJ]

Westerfield, David. Cooking Apparatus. Number 4717X, 1827 -- a David Westerfield was a mason, at 560 Pearl St.  It would make sense for a mason to be involved in designing built-in or brick-set kitchen ranges, as installation was part of their business and needed their craft's skills.  


Fuller, R. & Thomas, T. Coal-Grate Blower. Number 4765X, 1827 -- there were five Thomas Thomases in the 1827 Directory, but the most likely ran a kitchen furniture warehouse at 63 Nassau.  Robert Fuller, who lived next door, was his partner in a firm of gratemakers, Fuller & Thomas.


Hedenberg, Francis L. Portable Oven. Number 5085X, 1828 -- Hedenberg was a tinsmith at 386 Cherry Street, and still in the stove business three decades later.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Naylor, William. Stove. Number 5515X, 1829 -- Naylor was a tinsmith of 232 Church Street.  Another Naylor, Peter, followed the same trade at the corner of Broad and Water.  Though his patent neither survived the 1836 Fire nor was restored after it, it was considered sufficiently interesting and valuable to be included in the monthly summary of patents by the editor of Philadelphia's Franklin Institute, Thomas Jones.  As there was then no official publication detailing US patents, the Franklin Journal was the most important way in which this information became available to other inventors and manufacturers. 


Thomas P. Jones, "For an Improvement in Stoves; William Naylor, New York, June 11," in "American Patents. List of American Patents Granted in June, 1829. With Remarks and Exemplifications, by the Editor," Journal of the Franklin Institute Vol. 4:3 (n.s.) (Sept. 1829), pp. 169-94 at pp. 180-181. http://books.google.com/books?id=xdUFAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA181   


p. 180 This stove is formed in front like a parlour grate, for an open fire, and is to be used with any kind of coal, or with wood; anthracite coal being preferred. Behind the fire there is an oven, boilers, and //p. 181 other appendages, arranged after the manner of a ship's camboose. The whole seems to us to be compact and well arranged; its appearance, as represented in the drawing, is handsome; its parts, however, are too numerous for verbal description.     

Several very excellent cooking stoves have been invented in New York, and this, we think, will add one to the list.


There is a picture of a later model of it in the report on the "Seventh Annual Fair of the  American Institute, Held at Niblo's Gardens, October, 1834," Mechanics' Magazine, and Register of Inventions and Improvements 4:4 (25 Oct. 1834): 241-52 at p. 244.  




As we can see, it is a free-standing device with a coal grate and a front decorated with standard Federal Period motifs.  The smoke pipe was attached at the front, above the mantel, and the oven and boilers were accessed from the side, which cannot have been very convenient.  This stove could only have sat in an existing kitchen fireplace if the alcove was both deep and wide.  Even so, Naylor's was one of the best "oven Franklin" stoves available in the city in the late 1820s and early 1830s, winning a second premium at the 1834 American Institute Fair.  


Note the prominence of the maker's name, and the announcement that this was a patent device, on the oven door: marking goods in this way became standard practice, and testifies to the value for marketing their wares that makers put on the possession of a patent.  Patents, like prizes at manufacturers' fairs, gave customers some reassurance that, in an environment where the technology of cooking and heating appliances was quite new, unfamiliar, and fast-changing, and the market was increasingly crowded by competing makers and their claims, they could at least identify the best. 


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Schermerhorn, C. Coal Cooking Stove. Number 5544X, 1829 -- there is nobody of this name in the 1827 or 1834 Directories, but other Schermerhorns were ship chandlers on South and Washington, or merchants on Broome, South, and Water streets.   


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Davis, William & Lord, R.W. Coal [Anthracite] Cooking Stove. Number 5722X, 1829. Class 126/31.


There are too many William Davises in the 1827 and 1834 Directories for a confident identification to be possible, though the William Davis who was a smith at 278 Bowery and 222 Elizabeth is the best bet, and no R.W. Lord. However, in compensation, we have both pictures and a description for their device, which seems to have been more ingenious than practical, with only a small oven and just a single, awkwardly placed and shaped, cooking hole.  


Like a number of early patents, the US PTO archive and website only has the drawings for this stove, not the text.  However, the stove was described in the Franklin Institute's patent reviews, which quoted from the now-lost document: 


The fire is made in an open grate, with the bars formed in the usual way. The ends and flue part, or throat, above the grate, are of cast iron. The grate slides in, so that the fire stands under an oven, which oven allows the heated air to circulate round it. When fuel is put on the grate, it must be drawn forward. Behind the oven is a box, forming part of the flue, with openings for boilers, &c. "The whole is mounted on scroll legs, on the inside of which, and at the bottom of the grate, are flanches supporting a sliding pan, or hearth, to receive the ashes."


[Thomas P. Jones], "American Patents. List of American Patents Granted in November, 1829. With Remarks and Exemplifications, by the Editor," Journal of the Franklin Institute 5:2 (Feb. 1830): 126-140 at p. 136, http://books.google.com/books?id=290FAAAAYAAJ.




The drawings make these and other features quite clear.  There is also a James-style box hearth, for the ashes.  The stove was partly cast iron and partly wrought, which would make sense if Davis were indeed a smith.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Jennings, Joseph. Cooking Apparatus. Number 5961X, 1830. Class 126/"1/1".



There was a moulder of this name living at 70 Walnut Street in the 1835 Directory, and a person running a Free Emigrants' Office at 46 Waverly the previous year. But they were not necessarily the same man, and neither may have been the Joseph Jennings who patented this attractive brick-set cooking range, which doubled as a hot-air furnace for warming the upper rooms of a building.  


Jennings may have thought that this was an original idea, and the Patent Office accepted his claim, but in fact Oliver Evans of Philadelphia had had it first, put it into practice, and published it in his Young Mill-Wright's and Miller's Guide more than thirty years earlier, and Samuel Dickey of Chester County had then patented it himself in 1806.  (See "(Some of) The First Stove Advertisements in America.") This just goes to show how fragile patentees' claims to originality often were, and why a patent claim needed to be tested in court in order to be enforced.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Haggerty, William A. & Lawrence, C. Portable Cooking-Furnace. Number 5988X, 1830 -- Haggerty was a furnacemaker living on the corner of Gouverneur and Cherry streets, who remained in that business, at almost the same address, between his first appearance in 1834 and his last in 1848.  There is no obvious candidate for C. Lawrence.  


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Disbrow, Levi. Kitchen Grate. Number 6255X, 1830. Class 126/147.




Levi Disbrow was in business with his sons in 1834-1836 at 66 Bleecker Street as "Machinists & water borers: kitchen grate manufacturers, and tin & iron plate workers," and had invented what he called the "Jackson Grate, or Kitchen Range." As we can see, this was just a large, traditional cooking fireplace with an inset wrought-iron grate for coal and a swinging crane for moving cooking pots over the coals. It claimed to be "a sovereign remedy for smoky chimneys where anthracite coal is used" and also to be fuel-saving, because only one or two sections of the grate could be used if a smaller fire than the full three baskets would do the jobs required. 


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Roe, S.C. Conical Stove. Number 6404X, 1831 -- a Stephen C. Roe, MD, lived at 315 Fourth in 1834.


Tuthill, D.L. Furnace for Heating Hatters' Irons. Number 6831X, 1831 -- Daniel L. Tuthill was a hatter, at 202 Chambers in 1834.  His invention illustrates the way in which the use of heat in manufacturing processes led artisans other than metalworkers to experiment with developing specialized stoves for their own particular purposes.  



Mott, Jordan L. Anthracite-Coal Stove. Number 7096X, 1832. Class 126/68.


This was the first of Jordan Mott's many stove patents.  Given that I have written so much about him elsewhere (particularly "Jordan Mott's Anthracite Stoves"), and that the original documents are all available online, I won't repeat much of it here.  Mott's 1843 catalogue is an excellent, illustrated and explanatory guide to the development of his product line. 


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gassner, David. Coal Cooking Stove. Number 7163X, 1832. Class 126/1R -- David Gassner was a grocer of 131 West St., but J. & M. Gassner were tinsmiths with a shop at 227 Fulton.  All three Gassner ?brothers lived at 315 Washington. 





Gassner's invention was a free-standing iron range rather than a stove, with four cooking holes and a large central one.  There were two ovens at either side of an open-fronted fire in the middle, their sides protected from overheating by firebricks.  It was "particularly adapted for burning anthracite," and its advantage was said to be the "steady and uniform degree of heat which may be applied to all parts of the stove at the same time."


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Branch, Hardin. Generating Steam for Cooking. Number 7521X, 1833 -- not in 1834 or 1835 Directories. 


Disbrow, Levi. Combined Furnace and Steam-Boiler and Combined Furnace, Numbers 7568-7569X, 1833.


Mott, Jordan L. Magazine Stove. Number 7910X, 1833. Class 126/73.


Much more elegant than his 1832 patent -- pyramidal, fluted, and prominently marked on its front plate "J.L. Mott Patent." It claimed to combine the advantages of an open Franklin and a close stove, with an open-fronted anthracite grate, a boiling hole on top, and an ash drawer underneath.  The fluted chimney was "chiefly for ornament."


[1834 Directory http://books.google.com/books?id=dn0VAAAAYAAJ]

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hunt, Walter. Globe or Radiator Stove. Number 8006X, 1834.  Class 126/58.




This is the most extraordinary of surviving New York stove patents, with superb, detailed drawings and a fascinating backstory.  It's probably too fascinating to include all of it here, so I'll do a separate post and meanwhile just refer anybody interested to the shortened version that appears in "Chapter 5: The Rise of the Stove Foundry" (direct link to draft: http://goo.gl/0grwSy).


Even more briefly, Hunt was the first professional inventor to appear among the ranks of stove pioneers, his engineering expertise and originality visible in the design and expert drawings of his Globe Stove, its spherical cast-iron firepot engraved with a map of the world.  It was made to burn anthracite and to decorate as well as heat a room.  Its internal arrangement was as novel as its appearance, with a "rack and pinion or vibrating ... grate" and an annular damper at the base of the column to enable the user to control heat output.


Hunt appears in the 1834 Directory as a stovemaker with business premises at 103 Amos and a house at 282 Bleecker.  So does one of the merchants and religious fanatics with whom he went into partnership to make and sell his stove, Benjamin H. Folger, who shows up twice, as a [wholesale] hardware dealer at 99 Pear Street, and stovemaker at 102 Charles.  (The other, Elijah Pierson, a.k.a. Elijah the Tishbite, entered history in July, 1834, allegedly poisoned by a plate of blackberrries.)  Even after the partnership had been dissolved by death and scandal, the Globe stove continued to sell and to win prizes -- "Seventh Annual Fair of the  American Institute," Mechanics' Magazine 25 Oct. 1834, p. 242.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Payne, E.D. Cooking Stove. Number 8056X, 1834 -- in 1835 Payne lived at 97 Beekman, just off Water Street, but Longworth's Directory gives no business or occupation for him.  A Henry Payne was a smith (presumably black-) at 266 Water.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wilson, James. Union or Double Grate Heating Stoves. Number 8403X, 1834.  Class 126/500.



This is the first of Wilson's surviving or restored patents, taken out the year after his first insolvency, when he was re-entering business in partnership with, or sheltering behind, John or Joshua T. Gilbert.  It is an excellently drafted design, a proper engineering drawing for a very grand Open Franklin showing its sliding ash drawer, riddling grate, and chimney damper.  Its full name included all of its inventor's claims for it -- "Wilson's Improved Patent Pyramid Hot Air Guard Plate Union or Double Grate Stoves for burning all the various kinds of Anthracite Coal and all other flammable substances with the greatest economy adapted to all the varieties of situations such as meeting houses, halls, steamboats, selling rooms, counting houses, kitchen stoves, cabins &c &c on an entirely new principle never before known or used, in the United States."  A distinctive feature was the pair of cast-iron columns either side of the central fire, and the similar pair of tubes in the iron mantel, all meant to increase the fireplace's efficiency by circulating hot air through them.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hopkins, W.A. Cooking Stove. Number 8424X, 1834 -- the only W. (William) A. Hopkins in the 1834-1836 Longworth's Directories was a printer whose shop was at 2 Ann Street.  


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wilson, Carington, Jr. Cooking Stove. Number 8443X, 1834 and Cooking Stove. Number 8445X, 1834. Class  126/18.



The text of the patent is missing, but the drawings are clear enough -- this was an open-front anthracite cook stove with a large oven above the fire and a small one F behind it.  The blower D was a sliding shutter that lay on the hearth plate as an ash-collector when not in use, but could be swung through 90 degrees to cover the fire.  No boiler holes are shown in the top plate. Wilson was a leghorn hat bleacher, the son of a Broadway milliner.  What persuaded him to turn himself into a stove inventor is unknown and probably unknowable, but by 1852 he had moved into the stove trade full-time.



-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[1835 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric6018long]

Pike, B. Grate. Number 8684X, 1835 -- there were two B. Pikes in the 1835-1839 Directories, Barnabas and Benjamin.  Benjamin (with his son) was an optician with a business on Broadway; Barnabas moved around the city and had no reported trade or occupation, but as by 1839 he had business premises on Peck Slip, right next to Water Street, he seems the better bet.


Augustin, Ernst G. Stove for Cooking and Warming Rooms. Numbers 8945 and 8946X, 1835 -- not in any of the directories 1834-1836 or 1839. 




Mott, Jordan L. Heating Stove. Number 8983X (1), 1835. Class 126/500.


This was the first of Mott's distinctive stoves with a body constructed of cast-iron rings, bolted together, with an outside surface "fluted, ribbed, or grooved, so as to expose a larger surface to the action of the external air, as this mode of forming them, will tend to prevent their being over heated, by its extended radiation."  This was designed both to make his stoves lighter and more efficient and also to prevent fire-cracking as they went through repeated heating and cooling cycles. 



Mott, Jordan L. Anthracite-Coal Heating Stove. Number 8983X (2), 1835. Class 126/500.


The text of this version of the patent makes the design purpose even clearer -- "by which means any difference of expansion in the respective parts may take place without the danger of breaking, whilst any portion which is defective may be easily removed, and its place supplied."  This was a desirable feature in "apparatus, which are to be exposed to great alterations of temperature," which could include retorts for generating gas from coal.  


Nobody seems to have picked up on this idea of Mott's, and he did not stick with it for long himself either.  This may have been because greater experience in stove design, and improved molding techniques once he began to cast his own stoves in his own foundries rather than buying them from New Jersey stove furnaces, made it unnecessary.




Mott, Jordan L. Heating Stove Knob or Handle. Number 8984X, 1835. Class 126/219.


This was a small but useful feature -- a way of making stove knobs of zinc or spelter in metal or sand moulds, screwed together.  The interest of this patent is mostly that it shows Mott's growing experience as a manufacturer, and his interest in labor-saving methods.  Using this technique, "the cost of them is much diminished whilst they are equally well adapted to the intended purpose."  Mott, still recorded as a South Street [wholesale] grocer in 1834, moved into 248 Water alongside Charles J. Gayler, iron chest maker, and John L. Brown & Co., patent balance and scale-beam makers and general machinists, in 1835.



Smith, T.B. Cooking Range. Number 9063X, 1835 -- there was a Thaddeus B. Smith, shipmaster, of 549 Broome Street, but there was also a Thomas, no middle initial, who was a moulder living in the foundry district on Goerck Street.



Mott, Jordan L. Grate and Stove-Bar. Number X9166, 1835. Class 126/170; 172/751.

As with his stove knob, this is mainly interesting because of what it says about Mott's thinking.  His design made his grate "more economical and the vibrating and tilting motions are obtained by a very simple arrangement of the parts." The grate included a sliding shutter to prevent the escape of dust, a common customer complaint ever since William James had tried to deal with it via his box hearth. 


Mott was evidently now designing things with an eye to ease and cheapness of manufacture.  "[T]he grate and its bearings are delivered from the moulds in casting ready for action without any filing or other fitting or the addition of any sliding bar or pin or other appendage."  They were simple, with the minimum number of operating parts, and immediately ready for use in as-cast form.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gill, Bennington. Cooking Stove. Number 9285X, 1835. Class 126/1R.


Bennington Gill ran a hardware store at 206 Water, and was partner in (and the New York representative of) the Albany firm of Gill & French, stove makers.  He managed their supply chain -- pig iron and castings from the New Jersey furnaces -- and the sale and distribution of their products.


There are two more pages of detailed drawings.


His cooking stove was a transparent attempt to imitate, but hopefully not violate, the well-defended patent of his neighbor Myron Stanley at 244 Water, the New York representative of his brother Henry's furnace and foundry enterprise in upstate New York and Vermont.  Stanley's rotary cooking stove, patent number 7333X (1832), revised and reissued as 9282X in 1835 (lost in the Fire and not restored), and then as [new series] 91 in 1836, was the market leader in the 1830s.   

Other Stanley imitators tried to get around his patent by using a different mechanism -- e.g. a lever -- to rotate the top of the stove and bring cooking pots closer to or further away from the cook and the fire (for convenience in handling them, and controlling the amount of heat they received).  Gill made his stove circular too, but it did not rotate.  Instead, a complex arrangement of dampers enabled the cook to control the amount of heat applied to individual pots.


According to the always perceptive and often critical Thomas Jones, writing in his patent reviews in the Journal of the Franklin Institute 18:1 (July 1836): 39, "The difference between this stove and some which have been previously made is not very great and so far as we can judge from the description and drawings, which are by no means defective, we should much prefer one of Stanley's rotary stoves to it, as being less complex, and more convenient."


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


[1836 Directory http://archive.org/details/longworthsameric6118long]

Frazier, Thomas, Blanchard, Hiram, and Gill, Bennington. Cook Stove. No. 9621X, 1836. Class 126/1R -- Frazier was a stove manufacturer of 206 Water Street, 1834-1847, and at other nearby addresses until 1852; Blanchard was a pattern-maker of 250 Water Street; Gill we have already met.


This was just a modification for existing cooking stoves, claiming to control them better with the aid of a single flap-type damper in the flue above the oven.



Bennett, J. Grate. No. 9646X, 1836 -- J. Bennetts (James, Jeremiah, John, Joseph) are too numerous, and their occupations too varied and remote from the metal trades, for any to be identified with any confidence.



Anderson, William. Fire Place / Parlor Grate. No. 9765X, 1836.  Class 126/5 -- there were eight William Andersons in the 1836 Directory, none with a particular connection to the metal trades.  

His patent was for a cast-iron front, jambs, and hearth for an anthracite grate. He claimed that his design improved the grate's efficiency via polished reflectors on the jambs, and was adaptable to a Franklin stove as well as an ordinary fireplace.




Thorp, Gould. Cooking Stove. No. 9778X, 1836. Class 126/"1/1" -- Thorp was a stove manufacturer, in business at 254 or other premises in the Water Street stove district between 1834-1856.  David Thorp was one of the witnesses on this patent -- Gould's partner from 1839, and eventual successor.


No drawings; this claimed to be an improvement on the Holly Stove Patent (probably P. Holley of Red Hook, No. 3462X, 1822), which was "well known and is now public property, and the specification whereof is in the Patent Office." Not since the 1836 Fire it isn't.



And that concludes the old series of pre-Fire stove (etc.) patents. Almost all of those from 1836 onward have surviving patent drawings and texts, and there are also far more of them (138 through the end of 1855); so I will have to be more selective in only illustrating and commenting on those that were particularly novel, or influential, or otherwise significant.

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

First Stoves (& other things)

To celebrate the passing of a milestone -- 20,000 page-views for this blog, almost a tenth of them in the past month alone -- I am just going to gather together a bunch of my raw research notes which I flagged up with the label "Firsts" because they struck me, when I came across them (mostly in 19th-century local histories), as nice illustrations of the way stoves (and stove makers) served as symbols or markers of modernization in rural America.  These notes are pretty much as I took them, mostly by cutting-&-pasting from online sources.  I haven't checked the web addresses; they may not still be live.


* * *

Chase, Benjamin
History of Old Chester [N.H.] from 1719 to 1869 (##: 1869). http://books.google.com/books?id=wPZ_WbsPleEC

p. 412 "The first cooking stove in Chester was bought by Daniel French, Esq., in 1824. The next about the same time by Hon. Samuel Bell. The James pattern was perhaps the earliest here."

p. 424 "In 1815 William T. James of Lansingburgh, afterwards of Troy, made the stove known as the 'James stove,' which not only continued the leading cooking stove for nearly a quarter of a century, but may..."


Hammond, L. M.
History of Madison County, state of New York (Syracuse: ##, 1872).

Chapter X. 

LENOX

Lenox Furnace was another of the early enterprises of this town. It was located one mile south of Wampsville, and was, for a long term of years, the leading business institution of the town.

The "Lenox Iron Company" was organized in 1815... The first agent of the company was Lewis J. Dauby, of Whitestown, he being succeeded by Gardner Avery, who manufactured the first cast iron, in November, 1816. He operated the furnace successfully several years. William Cobb succeeded Mr. Avery, and was agent till 1827, when J. N. Avery received the agency, and continued till the business was closed in 1847, in consequence of the exhaustion of timber for charcoal, there being then no method of smelting iron with mineral coal. Iron ore was hauled to this establishment on sleighs, from Clinton, Westmoreland and Verona. The company manufactured hollow ware of all descriptions, including potash, caldron and salt kettles; also castings for plows, and all kinds of shop and cooking stoves in current use. They began in the stove line with the first invention -- "Dr. Noyes' [n10] Parlor Stove," then considered a great achievement. The first pattern of the "Franklin Stove" was also cast here, and we presume, also, the first cooking stove, invented by David Gage. Connected with the works were a number of dwelling houses, the general boarding house, a blacksmith shop, a carpenter and joiner's shop, and a store and office. The place bore the title of "Lenox Furnace Village," and was so given, conspicuously, on all the maps up to 1850.

[n10] Dr. Noyes was then a Professor in Hamilton College


Matthews, Alfred & Hungerford, Austin N.
The History of the Counties of Lehigh and Carbon, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (Everts & Richards: Philadelphia, 1884).

p. 675 THE FIRST ANTHRACITE STOVES MADE IN MAUCH CHUNK

... interesting facts concerning the manufacture of the first stoves in which it was used as a fuel.  John Mears, a sheet-iron and tin-plate worker, established himself in the town during the first decade of its existence, and very soon engaged in making stoves in which the fuel so abundant in the neighborhood could be utilized for heating and cooking.

Asa L. Foster, a man of much mechanical genius, spent a great deal of time in experimenting to perfect coal stoves, and many of his plans were carried out by Mears.  Apropos of early stove manufacture in Mauch Chunk, we make some extracts from a letter written by John Mears to Thomas L. Foster:

Philadelphia, Aug 20, 1879

"I remember well all the efforts that were made at an early day in regard to stoves, and their subsequent failures, but you give me undue credit in reference to the contrivances which were made to perfect the art of cooking with (anthracite) coal, two or three of which you mention.  Your father was the inventor of these things, while I only did the work, and he spent much time and money upon them, with the success that commonly attends ingenious men, though, as nothing is lost, the ideas he suggested were carried out by others, some of whom have made fortunes and gained fame through different patterns of stoves, some of them of value and some not.  I presume that John Wilson, who so much delighted to be called 'John Wulson the tinker,' a man of rough habits and manners, but a good-hearted soul, nevertheless, made the first stove that ever was used for burning anthracite coal.  This John was one of the first eighteen workmen who came up with Josiah White and Erskine Hazard from the Falls of the Schuylkill in 1818, and commenced operations at Mauch Chunk.  The stove was a plain, round, sheet-iron
cylinder, such as you may have seen since, with fire-door, tearing-door, ash-pit, with drawer to carry off the ashes, and a screen under the grate, made also of sheet-iron, with holes punched in it.  I have made several of them.  John Wilson also made the first baking-stove I ever saw.  This was an improvement, or rather an addition, upon the other stove, by which an oven was placed on the top, and flues to carry off the coal-gas and lead it up the pipe.  This was a rude article, but answered the purpose.  I also made several of them, but with a square oven instead of round, and they were good bakers.  Samuel Lippincott afterwards tried to utilize the old-fashioned ten-plate stove by putting an additional story on the lower part, in order to make space for the coal-furnace.  This was only a partial
success, and did not last long.  The //p. 676 first attempt at warming by heated air was, I think, made by my father, at No. 3 Broadway, where we then lived.  This was effected by a chamber back of the open grate in the parlor, and a hot-air pipe passing from the same to the chamber above. 

"I ought to mention in this connection that after this Josiah White had a more elaborate concern at his house on the hill, made also by John Wilson, and it worked well, as I believe, while it lasted, which was not long, for being made of thin iron it soon rusted away, and was abandoned.

"Before I close this subject I ought perhaps to tell you how we improvised a fire lining for the primitive stoves.  A wooden drum was made two inches less the diameter of the stove, with slats nailed round a short distance from each other and large auger-holes bored in each end.  This drum was filled with shavings and chips, then put in the stove, and well-mixed sand and clay rammed down between the iron and wood.  When all was finished fire was applied to the cotton, and, when partially burned, other wood was put in and then the coal.  This was the kind of 'cylinder' used in Mauch Chunk for many years, and, I believe, lasted as long as most of those of modern manufacture.

"I am your friend, as ever,


Copeland, David S.
History of Clarendon from 1810 to 1888 (Buffalo: Courier Co., 1889).

p. 47 1819 frame school house: "In the frame school-house at Clarendon the
entrance was to the north-west, showing the love of cold weather; the teacher's desk opposite the door, so as to see the scholars when they came in. In 1822 there were two large fire-places in this school-house, with plenty of wood to burn, and they were kept roaring during the winter-time.  As time advanced the stove came in that would burn four-foot wood, and this must have been somewhere about 1840. By this box-stove lay a large iron poker, which some village blacksmith had pounded out, big enough to stir up the fire, or knock any of the larger boys down, if //p. 48 necessary."

p. 141 [the Hines place] "the first stove to give forth its cheerful heat was the Bloodhound."

p. 169 "Samuel L. Stevens was born in 1801, and came into Clarendon in 1813
with his father, John Stevens, and lived at first on the present lands of Daniel Barker, under a bark roof, with basswood floor, and a blanket for a door. The first stove Samuel remembers was the Wilson [REREF hjh], and the Franklin, with open grate, for parlor."

p. 189 [old log-house] "The first carpet that Eunice had she wove with her own hands, and it was made from woolen rags; and she also wove woolen blankets to cover the sleepers. The first stove in this house was //p. 190 from Le Roy, and had two griddles, with a fire-place in front; and this stove would burn chunks." {a James ??}

p. 205 STORIES. -- MRS. CURTIS COOK'S STORY

b. 1804 -- frontier girlhood described

"Our house had no boiler until the stove came." -- open-hearth cookery

p. 207 "In 1824, I saw a stove in Batavia, when I worked there, and I cooked over it for three months. It had a place on which to broil steak, venison and chicken. The first stove I had was only one griddle, and was only for boiling, with no legs, but bricks."


Turner, Orsamus
History of the Pioneer Settlement of Phelps and Gorham's Purchase, and Morris' Reserve (Rochester: W. Alling, 1852).

p. 499 PALMYRA: 

"Soon after 1818, and before the completion of the canal, there was a large accession to population, merchants and mechanics.  Pliny Sexton,() commenced there as a silver smith and watch repairer, in 1819 or, '20; afterwards, was one of the first to introduce the cooking stove into W.N.() York; engaged in the hardware business; and is now associated with George Cuyler in the banking business."


Slaymaker, Henry C., compiler
History of the descendants of Mathias Slaymaker who emigrated from Germany and settled in the eastern part of Lancaster county, Pennsylvania, about 1710 (Lancaster, PA: n.p., 1909).

p. 18 There is a tradition extant to the effect  that the first anthracite coal used in Lancaster was at Slaymaker's Hotel. It was so hard that they had great difficulty in igniting it, but after it got fairly started, the stove  got so hot that they did not know what to do with it. Being  afraid that the house would take fire, they poured water  on it, and then took the stove out doors, vowing if they ever  "got the pesky thing out, they would go back to burning  hickory wood at three dollars a cord."


Thwaites, Reuben G.
Early Western Travels, 1748-1846 (Cleveland, OH: A.H. Clark, 1907), vol. 12

Part II of Faux's Journal

p. 11 leaves PRINCETON, 1 Jan. 1820

p. 17 [Somerset, Ohio ??] -- "Warmed at an old quarter-section man, a Dutch
American, from Pennsylvania. He came here 11 years since.... p. 18 Has a fine stove below, warming the first, and all other floors, by a pipe passing through them."


Buley, Roscoe C.
The Old Northwest: Pioneer Period, 1815-1840, Vol. 1 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1950).

p. 221, n. 201: "One of the first advertisements noted in the West was that
of 'C. Postley's Patent Cooking Stoves, or Portable Kitchens,' in the Liberty Hall and Cincinnati Gazette, August 25, 1821.  Franklin and cooking stoves were for sale in Cleveland in the middle 1820's.  See cuts in Cleveland Herald, October 6, 1826. 

'...up to 1828 there was no such thing known as a cast stove. John Sheets brought a seven-plate stove from the east to town [Madison, Indiana] for his stove, but there were no cook stoves until 1835 or '36. It was stipulated when I got my wife that I was to furnish a cooking stove for our kitchen.' Lewis, 'Pioneers of Jefferson County,' in ... 


Briggs, Erasmus
History of the original town of Concord: being the present towns of Concord, Collins, N. Collins, and Sardinia, Erie County, New York (Rochester: Union & Advertiser Co.'s Print, 1883).

p. 123 Sixty years ago frame houses began to take the place of the log ones. In structure they differed but little from those of to-day-save in one feature--every main room in the house whether parlor, sitting-room or kitchen, was supplied with an open fire-place. That in the kitchen was much larger and always so arranged that it contained a brick oven in one of the jambs. This oven was used as often as once a week to do the family baking, and around the kitchen fire, usually, the family passed the long winter evenings. The children in reading or conning lessons that must be recited to the district pedagogue the following day, in peeling beech nuts or roasting chestnuts in the embers, or cracking butternuts in the corner.
Perhaps an elder member of the family would read aloud "Tales of the Arabian Nights," "Thaddeus of Warsaw," or the fate of poor "Charlotte Temple." But change, inexorable change is stamped on everything that pertains to kitchen life of 60 years ago. The range and cook stove have supplanted the fire place of our father's time, with its ruddy and welcome cheer, and in its banishment vanished many of the fondest joys that belong to childhood's home and years. {QUOTE} The good wife's household burdens may have been greatly ameliorated by the new order of things, but when modern improvement invaded the old-fashioned kitchen, and banished the "ingleside," we felt it to be sacrilege, and as a descendant of the pioneers, we feel called upon to earnestly protest against the change. Think of listening to "folk-lore," or fairy tales by the side of a coal stove, or playing "blind man's buff," and "hunt the slipper" around a range. No, we say it, and without fear of contradiction, that when the fireplace was banished from our American homes, one of its sacred and most endearing altars was destroyed. The old fireplace with its endearing associations has attuned many a lyre, and poets have sung its praises. No fool of a poet ever attempted to immortalize a coal stove or cooking range in verse; nor ever will. Coal and cast-iron are too practical and only used to "save fuel."

We are not in enmity to the cook stove in its proper place, but the family sitting-room should be supplied with an open fire, //p. 124 either of wood or coal. It is far healthier and a thousand times pleasanter. 

p. 294 Jedediah S. Barnett was born in Sullivan, Madison county, N. Y., came to
Springville in 1834. While engaged in the foundry business with his father, he cast the first cook stove and plow made in town. He was proprietor of the foundry at Springville for a while and was employed for twelve years in the foundry at Gowanda, N. Y. He was married Dec. 25, 1839, to Lydia Demon.


Brown, Abram E.
History of the Town of Bedford, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, from Its Earliest Settlement to the Year of Our Lord 1891 ... with a Genealogical
Register of Old Families (Bedford: Author, 1891).

p. 102 "The first cooking stove owned in town was used here by George
Fisk." -- c. 1824 (not earlier than)


Morris, John E.
The Resseguie Family: A Historical and Genealogical Record of Alexander
Resseguie of Norwalk, Conn., and Four Generations of His Descendants
(Hartford, CT: Case, Lockwood & Brainard company, 1888).

p. 37 "In 1824 Mr. Riggs built the largest dwelling house in the town,
where his children and their families often met, to the number of thirty or
forty. On one of his visits to Albany he purchased a cooking stove, which
was the first one used in the town of Groton."


History of Muskingum County, Ohio, WITH ILLUSTRATIONS AND BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES OF PROMINENT MEN AND PIONEERS (##: J.F. Everhart & Co., 1882).

p. 95 TIN AND COPPER SMITHS. -- John Dulty, Sen., from Wheeling, Va., started
his son George in this business in 1809. About the first work he did, was to make the ball for the top of the cupola of "old 1809," court house. George returned to Wheeling and was succeeded by his brother John, in 1811, and he returned to Wheeling soon after and remained until after the close of the war of 1812, when he returned and continued the business alone until 1826, when his brother Michael joined him. In 1830, they built a two story brick store, where Bennett's jewelry place now is, and did a wholesale and retail business. They sold the first cook stove, out of a store in this county, in 1826. In 1843, Michael withdrew. In 1850, he bought the concern of his brother, and continued the business until the fall of 1854...


Butler, Jos. G., Jr.
History of Youngstown and the Mahoning Valley, Ohio (Chicago: American
Historical Society, 1921), Vol. 1.

Chapter 35. ORE AND COAL MINING

p. 769 The earliest settlers were aware that coal existed in this locality, as they found it cropping out on the hillsides, encountered it in sinking wells and even found it when digging cellars for their houses. They paid little attention to the mineral, however, as they did not need it for fuel and could see no other purpose for which it was valuable. Blacksmiths and furnace men used charcoal, and the few steam boilers were fired with wood, which was likewise the only domestic fuel known.

The first coal mine in the Mahoning Valley of which there is any record was opened in 1826 on land owned by Mary Caldwell, in Crab Creek, within what is now the City of Youngstown. The first coal used for domestic purposes in a stove was burned at Col. William Rayen's hotel in the same village about 1829, this stove having been brought from Pittsburgh by James McCay as a curiosity. The novelty of the idea appealed to Colonel Rayen, who bought the stove and fired it up with coal for the benefit of his guests. {QUOTE}

Some coal was doubtless used by blacksmiths and as household fuel from that
time on, for mines were opened at a number of places, one of these being Brier Hill, where David Tod began taking the mineral out in a small way. The Brier Hill coal was the best to be found in the valley, and the deposit there was also among the most extensive. It was soon found to be a most excellent fuel and Tod, always on the alert for opportunity to develop a new source of wealth for the community, made a number of trips to Cleveland and finally persuaded some of the concerns operating steamboats on the lakes to try Brier Hill coal in place of wood. There was much opposition on the part of boat captains and crews, but a trial proved that coal was far superior to wood, requiring less work in stoking, as well as less room in the boats. The first coal shipped from the Mahoning Valley was sent to
Cleveland in two canal boats, or barges, in 1841, and from that time forward the mining industry prospered. In 1845 it was found that raw Brier Hill coal, as well as the Mahoning block coal generally, made an excellent blast furnace fuel, and this still further encouraged the development of mines. Tram roads were laid direct from every mine of importance to the furnaces and the canal, and later to the Cleveland & Mahoning Railroad, and the work of taking out and shipping the fuel went on at a rapid pace. 

By 1870 the coal mining industry had reached its zenith, and from that time began to decline, as mine after mine emptied the basin in which it was located and the vein thinned out so as to become unworkable. ....

p. 771 -- already "a thing of the past" with few surviving physical traces by time of writing.


Taylor, William A.
Centennial History of Columbus and Franklin County, Ohio (Chicago: S.J.
Clarke Publishing Co., 1909), Vol. 2.

JOHN LORIMAN GILL.

John Loriman Gill was born in Boston, Massachusetts, on the 14th of February, 1806. ... At the early age of fifteen John L. Gill was left an orphan with six
younger brother and sisters. In 1822 he located in Pittsburg and placed two
of his sisters in Braddocksfield Seminary. In 1826 he came to Columbus and
with Colonel James A. Greer, of Dayton, established the business of handling stoves and the manufacture of other things. This was probably the first manufactory located in Columbus. These stoves were made for him at the old Mary Ann furnace, then located near Newark, Ohio. About 1827 or 1828 he took four six-horse wagon loads of stoves to Athens; and on the trip saw a blacksmith using coal. Inquiry developed that the coal dug was //p. 814  from the Athens hills. The blacksmith was induced to dig sufficient coal to load the wagons on their return trip. On arrival in this city the coal was sold to W. A. Neil, Sr., at sixty cents per bushel or fifteen dollars per ton, and used for blacksmithing purposes in connection with the stage coach line. ...  This was the first coal brought to Columbus and was the beginning of the immense coal traffic. Mr. Gill afterward owned many acres of this coal land. He was the first president of the Board of
Trade, and in 1890 delivered an interesting address before that body, in which the above facts were given.

Mr. Gill, seeing in use on Ohio river boats sheet-iron stoves for cooking purposes, adopted the plan and had patterns made for the same kind of stove in cast iron, and it is believed that this was the first square cook stove ever made. Prior to this time nearly all the cooking was done in Dutch ovens and skillets. Mr. Gill was a member of the firm of Buttles & Gill, the first commission and forwarding house to receive consignments of merchandise and produce by canal from the north and forward the same by wagons to Cincinnati and other points south and west of Columbus. In connection with the firm of Gill & Glover he erected a foundry at the foot of Town street, ... and there manufactured stoves. plows, mill-gear and
agricultural implements. This was in the '30s. About 1858 Mr. Gill invented and patented the movable cast-iron point for the combination steel plow, and now probably more than a million of these plows are manufactured each year. He was one of the chief promoters of the Columbus Gas Works, and for years was the largest stockholder in the company. Through his energy and enterprise many industries were induced to locate in Columbus, and he played a prominent part in making Columbus a railroad center. ...  In 1862 he bought the old Ridgeway and Kimball works on the west side, which had previously been partly consumed by fire, and commenced the manufacture of freight cars, which were sold direct to the Federal government. The old foundry at the foot of Town street was continued, at which place, for a time, the car wheels and castings were made for the cars. He built the first refrigerator car. These car works were continued by Mr. Gill until
1884, and grew from a few employes until as high as eight hundred and fifty
names appeared on the payroll. He owned several brickyards and manufactured
brick in large quantities. He owned a great deal of valuable real estate in and about Columbus. In early times a large portion of business was transacted on the credit and barter system, and owing to this custom his losses were at times very heavy.


Lewis, James E.
Pioneers of Jefferson County.  Reminiscences of James E. Lewis

from Madison Courier, Dec. 1874

Up to 1828 there was no such thing known as a cast stove.  John Sheets brought a seven plate stove from the East to town for his stove, but there were no cook stoves until 1835 or 36.  It was stipulated when I got my wife, that I was to furnish a "cooking stove" for our kitchen. 

[Jefferson County, INDIANA -- settled in 1800s.  Lewis = b. 1811, to
Madison c. 1816]

see also in http://books.google.com/books?id=SDr5Eqxl3xUC&pg=PA214 James B. Lewis, "The Pioneers of Jefferson County, 1. Reminiscences," pp. 214-27
from Indiana Magazine of History 12:3 (Sept. 1916), quote at p. 221


Clarke, S.J.
History of McDonough County, Illinois (Springfield, IL: D.W. Lusk, 1878).
http://www.archive.org/stream/historyofmcdonou01clar#page/n8/mode/1up

Ch. 11 HOME LIFE AND AMUSEMENTS

p. 108 -- settlers' log cabins: "huge fire place, large  enough to contain a back log as heavy as any man would care to  carry, and holding enough wood to supply an ordinary stove a  week;"

p. 122 early settler, 1829-: "Mr. Woods brought the first  stove ever seen in McDonough County, - a stove that was a great  wonder in its day. We have heard of women making their bread,  and carrying it a distance of nine miles to have the honor of  baking it in that stove. Mr. Woods has yet a portion of it."


History of McDonough County, Illinois (Springfield: Continental Historical Co., 1885).
http://www.macomb.com/~ilmcdono/settlement/earlysettlement.html

"The first cooking stove was brought into the county of McDonough by Salem
Woods, to Pennington's Point, in 1832.

James M. Campbell brought the second one to the county."


De Forest, Heman P. & Edward Craig Bates
The History of Westborough, Massachusetts. Part I. the Early History
(####).
http://books.google.com/books?id=GIADzlSUehYC&pg=PA224

p. 224 "The business of the place felt the coming of the railroad and its facilities at once, though it did not increase with the rapidity of later times.  In 1833 John A. Fayerweather opened a store in the Elijah Burnap house, and a year later started a stove and tin shop ... In 1836 he moved his variety store to ... the north side of Main Street, and continued to do business there, with various changes in the firm, until 1858.  It greatly astonished the good people of that day when Mr. Fayerweather, in the first store he opened, undertook to sell meal. It was an unheard-of thing that any one should think of buying meal anywhere but at the mill. Everybody said it would be a failure; but it proved a great convenience, and  soon superseded the old way."


Devoy, John, comp.
Rochester and the Post Express: A history of the City of Rochester from the earliest times; the pioneers and their predecessors, frontier life in the Genesee country, biographical sketches; with a record of the Post Express (##: 1895).
http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~nymonroe/bios/biographies018.htm 

pp. 201-202

WILLIAM H. CHENEY

William H. Cheney was born in Newport, New Hampshire, March 5, 1807. His parents were William and Tryphena H. Cheney. His father was a merchant, a
man of indomitable energy, and principal founder of Sullivan county, New
Hampshire. Mr. Cheney was educated at Windsor, Vermont, and commenced his
business life as a merchant in his native place. In 1836 he removed to Albany, New York, and engaged in the iron business. In 1838 he came to Rochester and immediately rented of Dr. Elwood the old Gilbert warehouse which stood at the upper end of the canal bridge on South St. Paul street, at the junction of the feeder with the Erie canal. He put in an engine and boiler and started an iron foundry, in which he cast the first cooking stove made in this part of the country. It was of an old "saddle-bags" pattern gotten up in Philadelphia. He remained there for eight years when he erected a brick building on St. Paul street near Court, removed his furnace and soon commenced us architectural iron works, making fronts, columns, etc. He stayed in this place and continued in active business
until 1879, when his health began to fail. Mr. Cheney was one of the builders and owners of the Genesee Chief, a propeller which was built at Charlotte for passenger and freight traffic on the lakes. He was also one of the owners of a large blast furnace near Sodus Bay. In politics he was in early life a Whig afterwards he became a Democrat, and remained so until his death. In 1845 he was elected supervisor of the Third ward. He repeatedly declined to become a candidate for mayor. He was one of the earliest elected trustees of the Rochester Savings bank, and was at one time vice-president. He was for a number of years president of the old Eagle bank. He was the first president of the Humane society, then called the Bergh society, in which he was greatly interested. His ear was always open to the cry of distress from brute as well as human. ...


Federal Writers' Project
The Ohio Guide (New York: Oxford U.P., 1940). -- 3rd printing, 1946
http://books.google.com/books?id=8MEi95NfEecC&pg=PA56

p. 56 "The first contest of a manufacturers' group and a national union occurred at Cincinnati in 1868, when the American National Stove Manufacturers' and Iron Founders' Association in convention voted to test their strength by cutting wages of local foundry workers 60 per cent. After 9 months the employers, refusing to arbitrate their radical wage cut, finally broke the strike. The union turned to the 'radicalism' of co-operative foundries."

p. 283 [HAMILTON] -- "The ESTATE STOVE COMPANY PLANT ... founded in 1842,
covers 13 acres. Originally manufacturing skillets, stove lids, and heavy castings, the company has gradually extended its line of products, and today is one of the world's largest stove makers."

p. 500 LAFAYETTE -- Red Brick Tavern, built 1837: "In the long dining room and kitchen to the rear was installed the county's first cook stove. It was viewed suspiciously by some people as an invention of the devil that would 'keep people from doing an honest day's work.'"


Montgomery, Morton L.
Historical & Biographical Annals of Berks County, Pennsylvania (Chicago:
Beers Publishing Co., 1909).
http://berks.pa-roots.com/books/montgomery/p01.html

p. 823 JOHN R. PAINTER (deceased), who for many years was one of Reading's
prominent business factors, was born Jan. 19, 1823, in Chester county, Pa., son of John and Margaret (Thomas) Painter. The parents of Mr. Painter were also natives of Chester county, but they were of Scotch-Irish ancestry. The father was a farmer in moderate circumstances, who lived and reared his family in the neighborhood of St. Mary's, where he gave them every advantage in his power as to schooling and position in life. ...

John R. Painter was still a child when his father died, in 1829, and only a youth when his mother passed away ten years later. His education was obtained in the common schools of Chester county and he supported himself by working for neighboring farmers until he was eighteen years of age, when he secured a position with the Isabella Furnace Company. There he learned the molder's trade, which he followed at Spring City, Philadelphia and Linfield, until 1867, when he was considered a competent and experienced man in this business. In the year mentioned Mr. Painter came to Reading, where in association with Jess Orr, Jasper Sheeler, Elijah Bull, Henry Posey, William Schick, Peter Nagle and others, he organized the Reading Stove Works. This firm did an immense business from the start, each member being skilled in the various departments of the industry. The plant was enlarged from time to time to meet increased demands and it became one of the largest stove foundries in Pennsylvania. Their trade connections
covered the whole world. This company had the reputation of never having
discharged a man who did his duty, and a remarkable fact is that workers were so anxious to enter the employ of this just firm that applications would be filed years ahead, many waiting for mechanics to die to fill their places.

In this company Mr. Painter's personality largely entered. While he possessed business keenness and executive ability of a high order, his character was that of a man of high principles and no man could ever rightfully accuse him of injustice. His charities increased in proportion to his means, and as he was wholly without ostentation, the world will never know the extent of his good deeds. His relations with his associates and with his army of employes were cordial and friendly and the latter knew that in him they always had a friend. Personally his tastes were simple and his happiest hours were those spent at his own fireside. His lamented death
took place Dec. 12, 1883, after an illness of two years duration. His afflictions were borne with patience and forbearance. The death of such a man as John R. Painter was indeed a loss to Reading, where his memory will long remain green.

Mrs. Painter resides at No. 454 Douglass street. When a young girl she united with the Reformed Church, and she has been prominently identified with the work of that denomination to the present time. Mr. Painter was a member of St. Peter's M. E. Church. In politics he was a Republican. He was a charter member of Welcome Lodge, I. O. O. F., of Philadelphia.

p. 1537 Charles E. & William H. Sproesser -- Charles b. 1821, blacksmith in
Germany, pattern fitter in US with Leibrandt & McDowell -- comes to Reading 1868 to work for Orr, Painter -- 1873 goes into hotel business; bro. William stove molder with L & M, comes to Reading 1868 too: 

"On March 1st of this year he made the first cook stove manufactured in Orr, Painter & Company's stove works, and he continued with that firm until 1873, when he engaged in clerking in his father's hotel."


Meginness, John F.
History of Lycoming Co. Pa. Illustrated (Philadelphia: D.J. Stewart/J.B.

John B. HALL, Geneva, NY & 2 foundrymen from Auburn seek foundry site, summer 1831

p. 40 find small foundry at MILTON on W. Branch, started in 1830 by Jos. Rhoads, coppersmith

* WILLIAMSPORT because proposal in 1832 from local Dr. & another inexperienced local investor

"A bargain was made, and Mr. Hall went to work to build his engine, boilers, cupola, and all the tools, etc., necessary to make iron." -- at first 40 x 60, soon enlarged 60 x 80 

* equipment made in Geneva, brought to W'port by wagon June 1832, ready to
start castings by start Sept: 

"This was the first engine in the West Branch Valley, and the first foundry in this County, Tioga, Centre, or Bradford, and many other counties west of this. He brought the patterns to town for the first coal stoves, and made and sold all used in town, and for fifty miles around, for some years."

* focus = steam saw mill equipment -- for "vast pine and hemlock" forests

"He brought a few mill-gearing patterns for grist, and also saw-mills, of the old style used in those days..., plow patterns, etc. 

Novelty of the Business ... When they commenced running the engine and melting the iron, the foundry was crowded with people every day they took a heat, which at first was only two days in the week."

* Transport problems -- coal & iron -- wagon, river boat, arks during high water, because CANAL not completed

* 1833 contract with STATE for railroad castings (Phila.-Columbia)

* story of first canal shipment from Lock Haven/Williamsport

* importance for building local industry

* 1840 new buildings incl. machine-shop, wareroom, smith-shop, office, wood-turning & pattern shop, tin- & copper-smith shop "now used as iron-railing shop and show-room for stoves and railing" -- 90 x 90 site

p. 125 "Mr. John B. Hall was born in Geneva, N. Y., June 1, 1804. When a boy  he learned the blacksmith's trade of his father. It is rather a coincidence that  Mr. Hall, his father, his grandfather, and great-grandfather were all workmen of this trade; also his maternal grandfather, General John Burrows. ....

Having learned the foundry business from his father, and worked at it for some years, he located in Williamsport in the summer of 1832, and was the builder of the first foundry and machine-shop in this place."


John F. Meginness, 
History of Lycoming County Pennsylvania (Chicago: Brown, Runk & Co., 1892).
http://books.google.com/books?id=NQFu5DfPSvwC&pg=PA351
         
p. 803 HALL -- "He received a fair education and learned the blacksmith trade." -- works for his father "who promised to give him his shop and tools upon reaching hi majority. ... afterwards clerking in a store for a few years. About 1825 he formed a partnership with his father and did a prosperous business in a foundry at Geneva until 1832. Their beginning was the manufacture of ploughshares () by hand-power and subsequently by engine." ...


Myers, Eloise S.
A Hinterland Settlement: Tyringham, Massachusetts and Bordering Lands
(Pittsfield, MA: Eagle Printing & Binding Co., n.d.). 
http://archive.org/details/hinterlandsettle00myer

p. 66 FORTY YEARS AGO (poem composed for Frederic Cone's wedding
anniversary, 1871):

"How wondrous are the changes Fred, / Since forty years ago;

[Clothes, school, homespun, hard & early work, sleds, wagons, oxen]

O, well do I remember, Fred, / That Wilson's patent stove / That father
bought and paid for / In cloth our gals had wove; / And how the neighbors
wondered / When we got the thing to go, / They said 'twould bust and kill
us all / Some forty years ago."